That or there's only a few of us who actually really, really, really care about graphics. I rely very heavily on visual stimuli and we all have different reasons why we appreciate gaming. While I enjoy how a game plays like everyone else I take most of my pleasure from just looking at the games. So to me this is a topic that's near and dear. :)
What's really important for a game to be visually successful you have to make sense, I appreciate an environment where every element meshes perfectly together and nothing sticks out like a sore thumb or in some case sticks out because they are way more beautiful then anything else in the game. I like a well rounded visual experience and not every mmo is capable of offering this due to performance issues mostly. Sony in my book is guilty of cutting corners and stripping textures down to a sloppy pixelated mess when attempting to make games perform on slower systems. It's horrifying. Which is why poor Eq2 doesn't make it very far up my list even though that game has some amazing textures in certain areas and why Vanguard doesn't even make it. And now I'd like to move on to the games that to me have the very best graphics in the MMO sphere.
Age of Conan clearly deserves the number one spot, everything is on the same level graphically when it comes to quality. I can't really say that anything suffers visually because of performance balance and the reason it's so is because Funcom funnels people into instanced zones. You may not like this idea but you have to admit a game that does this can really push the graphics envelope to bursting, which AoC definitely does.
Ryzom is my second choice because the whole package fits together like chocolate, graham cookies and marshmallow. It's a delicious guilty pleasure for your eyes, the character models may not be to everyone's liking but to me they are so unique and beautifully done, not to mention very customizable. The artsy and ecological design of the world is very intriguing and just captivating, the colors are vibrant but not overwhelmingly so and you may find yourself running around just to try to see more cool and pretty sights.
My third choice is Final Fantasy XI, which might surprise some people considering how old the game is. But again the whole game graphically is on the same level of quality, models and environments just blend together in harmony. And if you're on the PC you can adjust the registry to push the background resolutions and you'll end up with a version better then the Ps2 or the 360. A game that can look gorgeous and stand the test of time like FFXI is a dream come true to me, I wish more MMOs took the stance of just making a great looking game playable on most rigs now and just keep tweaking them forever... And honestly I think devs have learned their lesson too.
And that's basically it for the best looking MMOs out right now, even the ones on the verge of releasing I have more issues with then those three visually, yes even beautiful Aion... And here's my top ten list for those interested, not everyone's going to agree (or no one will.. XD) but again my criteria is on how eye catching the graphics are in general and if they look like they all belong together, if the game has awesome character models but crappy ground textures or vice versa their ranking will suffer..












